Green to pink to blue: Companies’ dirty washing

You've heard of greenwashing - but what are pinkwashing and bluewashing? Dr Irene Garnelo-Gomez unpicks the unethical marketing practices of certain companies in our latest Leading Insight.

Growing awareness towards social and environmental issues is impacting our lifestyles. How? According to Deloitte’s research, UK consumers are behaving more sustainably nowadays, by avoiding single-use plastics, focusing on ‘local’ and ‘seasonal’ products and reducing overall consumption. But consumers are not interested in doing it on their own, they want businesses to help, and recognise their responsibilities as members of society.

Stakeholder pressure and the aim of gaining competitive advantage are driving organisations to engage in responsible and sustainable practices, to show they care, to show they are doing ‘their bit’. But in doing so, some pledge more than they do, and risk being accused of some type of ‘washing’.

Most people have heard of greenwashing, when companies mislead consumers regarding their environmental practices or the ‘eco’ benefits of a product or service. In fact, the media often talk about greenwashing, and even share tips on how to spot it.

However, ‘washing’ is not only done in relation to environmental claims, as socialwashing is unfortunately very common. For instance, the LGBT+ community has complained about the growth of pinkwashing, or the use of gay-friendly approaches when promoting an organisation or its products, while masking other negative actions.

Many firms have also been accused of bluewashing, specifically in the fashion industry and in relation to human rights issues. In this case, organisations commit to various principles proposed by the United Nations (hence the ‘blue’, as per the UN’s logo), such as those under the UN Global Compact or the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Yet while these form a big part of their public relations and advertising, there is little action to back them up.

What are the dangers of engaging in ‘washing’ behaviours?

We should start by acknowledging the environmental and societal consequences of these behaviours. If consumers are misled to buy ‘fake’ eco-friendly products, they would be unintentionally harming the environment (e.g. consuming sustainable products that, in reality, are not sustainable). If consumers support an organisation that sustainably innovates on one front, to disguise the wrongdoings in other areas of the business (e.g. working conditions), they could be unconsciously aggravating problematic social issues.

From the point of view of the organisation, we would all agree that these types of practices are morally wrong, but the dangers of ‘washing’ do not stop there. By saying that they are doing more than they actually are, organisations are negatively affecting consumers’ perceptions of the firm, leading to reputation damage. Reputations take years to be built, and minutes to be destroyed. Ultimately, those changes in reputation will impact loyalty, trust and overall performance.

What could organisations do to avoid these practices?

Of course, we should start with the basics: organisations should really commit to being responsible and sustainable. This will take time and effort, and for some organisations will entail a complete overhaul, revisiting the organisation’s mission, vision and values. But that is possible, and we have good examples of companies that have successfully done it.

In my view, organisations should focus on addressing issues that are ‘closer to home’, looking at the impact they create on an everyday basis (both environmental and social) and consider how they could be better managed. Once organisations have decided what social and/or environmental issues they are able to realistically address, they should define specific targets and goals in relation to each of them and assess how they are going to tackle them.

After the strategy is designed, it is time to communicate it. How to avoid being perceived as ‘fake’ or doing some type of ‘washing’? Be specific, be honest, explain your goals and what you are doing to achieve them, even if you are not there yet. Transparency builds trust, and trust leads to healthy relationships with consumers, investors and other stakeholders.

The solution to ‘colour washing’ is simple: be responsible, be transparent, and communicate accordingly. After all, regardless of the organisation’s size or purpose, any perceived ’bad behaviour’ will eventually come out in the wash.

Dr Irene Garnelo-Gomez

Irene is the module convenor and lecturer for 'New Directions in Business and Corporate Social Responsibility' (UG), ‘Marketing for a better, sustainable world’ (PG) and ‘Corporate Responsibility’ (MBA). She is also part of the teaching team for the Reputation and Responsibility module (MBA), delivering workshops and facilitating study trips nationally and internationally. Irene also supervises PhD students and UG and MSc dissertations.

Aiheeseen liittyvät uutiset ja tapahtumat

The Henley Partnership - Presenting for success

Henley Partnership: Webinar – Presenting for success

  •   27.9.2022 – 12:00 to 14:00
Presenting effectively is not a talent people are born with, it is a crucial and tangible skill that can create opportunities in all parts of life. The skills learnt and applied in this webinar will help you in every situation, whether you are pitching for business or investment, or engaging with suppliers, customers or staff.
The Henley Partnership - How to change absolutely anything

Henley Partnership: Webinar – How to change absolutely anything

  •   13.9.2022 – 12:00 to 14:00
  • Online 🌐
Everybody wants to change something, whether it is work, life, yourself or someone else. Founded on leading research and powerful evidence-based psychological principles, this webinar with Professor Damian Hughes will demonstrate how you can bring about positive change in your life.
The Henley Partnership - The Chimp Paradox: Getting the best out of yourself and others

Henley Partnership: Masterclass – The Chimp Paradox: Getting the best out of yourself and others

  •   7.9.2022 – 12:00 to 14:00
  • Online 🌐
When dealing with competing pressures it can be hard to meet the needs of your team alongside your own. Clarity, empathy and resilience are paramount skills for leaders and managers to influence the performance of others while maintaining their own focus. In this masterclass, you will build your skill to support your own productivity and wellbeing alongside successfully supporting and developing your team.