The Integrated Leader – Henley Business School Finland

The debate on what is debatable in leadership

Last month, I attended the annual Windsor Leadership Debate, held at the Royal Institution in London’s Mayfair. Windsor Leadership Trust is a charity founded 1981, that provides “transformational leadership programmes for senior leaders across all sectors, including corporate, public, military, education, faith and not-for-profit” (according to its website), and that operates within the grounds of the Royal castle adjacent to “that” chapel where Harry married Meghan.

Historic surroundings

The debate was held in the impressive lecture theatre most Brits know as the location for the Christmas science lectures first established by Michael Faraday in 1825. The Windsor leadership panel on this occasion had impressive credentials in the arts, business, diplomacy, charity and public service and the audience was equally interesting and qualified, mainly alumni and supporters of Windsor Leadership, including several Henley alumni and staff. I enjoyed the evening, particularly the wit and wisdom of the Right Revd Stephen Cottrell, Lord Bishop of Chelmsford, who came up with some epigrammatic gems. Meanwhile, members of the audience proposed a series of questions or remarks about what issues ‘leadership’ – as a phenomenon – faces. There were several reminders of the value of reflection in leadership learning and development, which was great to hear.

Too much agreement?

After the event it struck me that everyone in the room was basically in agreement. There was much nodding and quite a lot of (deserved) appreciation for the various opinions, and clearly a consensus around… around… well, this part was the tricky bit. Around what? This got me thinking more generally. What does it take to find the cutting (the leading?) edge in the leadership debate?What is there to be debated? Where is the contention? Where does the real work need to be done?

Is a leadership debate about arguing how best to define what leadership is?

Or is it about understanding the nature of the world (and ourselves) and the problems we face – to which, presumably, leadership turns out to be the solution?

We need to stretch ourselves

Much of what goes into and comes out of the leadership debate feels like the former. We put our energy into supporting or countering other people’s definitions of leadership and of the leader, and we may have lost sight of that contextual view as a result. The latter seems to be to be a deeper discussion, but is not where Management Education currently sits. Academia has often struggled to speak about our failure to ensure long-term and sustainable survival of the environment we depend on.

The new frontier of any debate for or about leadership (and therefore of the persona of the leader) must surely require a reflective process of finding raison d’être in the face of the innumerable and often insurmountable social, political, economic and environmental events that we admit we face.

Perhaps it’s going to be a bit of both. The main thing should be that we spark debate on that which is truly important.

Chris is Associate Professor of Management Learning and Subject Area Leader for Personal Development at Henley. He has over 24 years of experience in management education and training. Chris teaches on the MBA and runs corporate workshops and seminars related to management development in many parts of the world, including South Africa, central Europe and the Middle East. His research is focused on the use of Reflection in Personal Development in post-experience Management Education.

Related content

Becoming a better leader is about becoming a better person - Henley Business School Finland

Becoming a better leader is about becoming a better person

  • 24 Nov 2022
One of things that sets the Henley Executive MBA apart from other postgraduate programmes is the strong emphasis on personal development. It is great to systematically take time for personal reflection that is not focused on work objectives, but rather on balancing my personal needs with the external demands I’m facing. Identifying and resolving matters that stop you from being a better person are an integral part of the path of any leader who wants to develop.

Executive Certificate in Leadership online information session

  •   13.12.2022 – 08:30 to 10:00
  • Online 🌐
The Executive Certificate in Leadership is an in-depth leadership programme for experienced leaders and senior managers with significant leadership responsibilities. It is unique in its emphasis on developing leadership within the organisational context. During the programme, you will develop your leadership capability and learn how to maximise your team’s performance.
The Henley Partnership - ESG: Why should we care?

Henley Partnership: Masterclass – ESG: Why should we care?

  •   7.12.2022 – 16:30 to 18:30
  • Online 🌐
It is now clear that big investors will invest in organisations which are demonstrably committed to strong principles about the environment, society and how they are governed. This form of corporate activism is becoming the expected norm for organisations. What can this approach do for your business?